The Perils of Giving Advice to the Ones you Love
October 29, 2007 by Adam Sicinski
miWisdom today… When people go through periods of great difficulty in their lives, we naturally have a tendency to try and assist them through their problems by providing them with techniques and strategies that we believe will help them overcome their challenges. Is this really the right and just way to go about assisting a person in need?
First of all, what may appear to be the right way around a problem to us may not in fact be the most ideal solution for the other person. Yes, we may well have gone through a similar experience, or we may have heard or read about others overcoming this sort of challenge in their life. Yet, can we rightly justify the act of providing helpful advice without first truly understanding the other person and their experience from absolutely every angle imaginable? Because this is exactly what it will take to provide this person with the right and suitable answers they are after.
When we freely help others, do we even consider the repercussions of our good nature? Is what we are doing for them helping them in the long-term? Is this empowering the other person to overcome other similar challenges in their life without your ongoing support or influence? Or is your act of helping them through this problem actually making them dependent on you now and in the future? There is an old saying which identifies this principle clearly:
“Give a man a fish; you have fed him for today. Teach a man to fish; and you have fed him for a lifetime.”
There is also another saying which states:
“Give a man a fish; you have fed him for today. Teach a man to fish; and you can sell him fishing equipment.” - However, let’s leave that for another time
When people are in great difficulty they only seek one single “thing” to begin with. This one “thing” is so powerful that it may well be the trigger that will empower them to take the necessary steps and actions to overcome their challenge single-handedly. So what is this one “thing” they seek? It is assurance from someone who can show that they understand their problems and challenges. They are looking to connect with a person who will be there for them as a satellite bouncing ideas back and forth.
Once this person feels comfortable that someone understands them; that they have the support of someone who is supportive of their plight - now you can move onto the next step, which is all about empowering the person from within. To do this, one must learn to lead a conversation by asking the right questions that will allow the other person to think independently and reflect upon their life and circumstances.
Giving advice is much like the act of giving a man a fish. You will feed the person with a solution for today, but what will they have left for tomorrow and the uncertain future that awaits them. However, by asking insightful questions that encourages the other person to think in unique and creative ways, is very much like teaching them to fish.
By guiding the other person to seek their own answers within, is one of the greatest gifts one is able to give to a child, a family member, stranger or friend; because it is one of those gifts that just keeps on giving whether you are in this person’s life or not.
Next time someone is in difficulty, you might find it helpful to ask yourself the following set of questions:
- How can I provide this person with reassurance that I am there for them in their time of need?
- How can I show them that I understand them and their situation wholeheartedly?
- What insightful questions can I ask that will encourage them to think in a unique and creative way about their problems and predicament?
- What sorts of questions could I ask that may well empower this person to take immediate and positive action today?
- How else can I show them that I am supportive of their difficulties, problems or challenges without giving advice?
If you have a similar learning experience or would like to add to the list of questions, you may do so by commenting below.







teaching them to fish or teaching them to live you can see it either way but agreeably to give them the assurance to feel secure in themselves is the ultimate solution and then only then are they confident to fish, live.
And you may learn this from students younger than yourself after you have taught them!
when i was studying engineering, i had a course called microprocessors. I was hopeless in that subject and required major assistance. My sole aim was to make sure i did not fail the subject. I was successful in my aim as i made one of my friend complete a couple of assignments and cheated a bit during my examinations to make sure i just about managed to clear the course. I was so happy that i thought i owed my friend big time.
Recently, as i completed my graduation, I sat for a campus interview for Seimens. I was very confident in answering all the questions fired at me and was sure that i would be hired by the HR. But then the interviewer asked me ” Tell me something about microprocessors”. I sat there in front of him like a dead duck.
All my gratefulness to my friend had vanished in a second. I had really wished that he had taught me about semiconductors rather than just complete my assignment and ‘handed over a baked fish’.
I did not get recruited due to this one question.